U.K. Audit Regulator Encouraged to Slap Big 4 Wrists Slightly Harder


Despite what you might hear, Big 4 audit firms have it pretty easy when it comes to compliance. Yes, there a ton of rules to follow, but in the event that a firm, one (or several) of its partners and employees run afoul of those rules, the consequences range from a mild rebuke to a small fine to a brief time-out from accepting or pursuing clients.

This environment of relative impunity is not lost on anyone. Which is why this judge in the U.K. is recommending stiffer fines:

Misdeeds by the world’s “Big Four” accounting firms should be punished with much bigger fines, Britain’s accounting watchdog was advised in a report released on Tuesday.

“Fines greater than those that have heretofore been imposed may be appropriate in really serious cases,” former judge Christopher Clarke said in the study published by the Financial Reporting Council (FRC).

What are “really serious cases” you might ask?

“If one of the Big 4 firms was guilty of seriously bad incompetence, in respect of the audit of a major public company… a financial penalty of ten million pounds or more before any discount could be appropriate,” the report said.

Oh, man. Can I volunteer to establish the standards of “seriously bad incompetence”? The nuances of what constitutes mere “incompetence” and “seriously bad incompetence” would require an acute sensibility for the jackassery of auditor behavior, and I think I’m uniquely qualified to adjudicate these matters.

For example, I’d love to grapple with the question about the severity of an audit partner banging the chief accounting officer of a client. Or if a partner is a little too chummy with a CFO. Or if a firm’s leadership is engaged in elaborate cover-ups, or ignored widespread corruption for decades.

Yes, I think I could do an excellent job of deciding if these types of situations were worthy of an eight-figure fine that would have a limited success deterring audit firms from seriously bad incompetence. I stand ready for the call.


Image: iStock/maximkabb

Related articles

PwC Italy Partner Is Probably In a Lot of Trouble, You Guys

So, there was this accounting scandal in early 2017 at the Italian unit of British phone company BT, in which nearly two dozen people at BT Global Services, including its CEO, CFO, and head of Europe, knew about inflated revenues, bogus contract renewals and invoices, and made-up supplier transactions to “meet bonus targets and disguise […]

Ex-KPMG Partner’s Fraud Trial: Opening Arguments

A jury heard opening arguments in a Manhattan courtroom on Feb. 12 in the trial of a former high-ranking audit partner at KPMG who was charged with conspiracy and wire fraud for his role in a scheme to cheat the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board inspection process. David Middendorf and co-defendant Jeffrey Wada, a former […]