September 20, 2018

Slim Pickings For SIG, as It Settles on EY as New Auditor

While the U.K.’s Financial Reporting Council investigates Deloitte’s 2015 and 2016 audits of SIG, the building products distributor has selected EY as its new auditor, according to the Financial Times.

EY was the only Big 4 firm eligible to bid for the SIG contract, which according to The Times newspaper, is worth about £1.6 million a year.

Deloitte was out, as SIG dismissed Deloitte as the company’s auditor in May. KPMG was out because it is SIG’s internal auditor. And PwC was out because it has provided SIG with IT advice, posing a potential conflict of interest, according to the Financial Times article.

Outside of the Big 4, there wasn’t much competition for EY either:

SIG was also unable to ask Grant Thornton, Britain’s fifth-largest accounting firm, to participate in the tender process as the firm declared in March that it would no longer bid for FTSE 350 audit contracts because of the high costs involved and the difficulty of competing with the Big Four. …

BDO, Britain’s sixth-largest accounting firm, also bid for the SIG contract. Gervase MacGregor, a partner at the firm, said BDO was “very disappointed” to have not secured the audit.

“We did pitch, we thought we had a good chance, and we put a very good team on it. We are very disappointed, but it won’t put us off pitching for other large listed companies,” he said.

The FRC probe comes as SIG reviews its historic accounts after a whistleblowing allegation of potential accounting irregularities led to the suspension of some staff for overstating profits over several years, Reuters reported.

SIG said in February that it was working with Deloitte to ensure “the correct accounting treatment,” but in May, 78% of SIG investors voted against Deloitte’s reappointment as auditor.

[FT] [The Times] [Reuters]

Image: iStock/BrasilNut1

Related articles

Deloitte: Folding Like a Cheap Lawn Chair?

deloitte.jpgIs it possible that the spinelessness of the FASB is spreading some of the firms?
Motely Foley is reporting that MGM Mirage got the Big D to drop the going concern language from its “financial assessment” which we confirmed with the author, Bob Steyer, that indeed meant the audit opinion.
Doing a little digging on this whole sitch, we found that MGM has done some duct tape repairs to its balance sheet in order to convince its banks and Big D that nothing is fucked.
Deloitte, wanting to be troopers and all, probably just had to step back from the whole thing to get perspective. “Yeah, when you look at it from back here, $14.4 Billion in debt doesn’t really look that bad.”

MGM Back From the Brink — for Now
[Motley Fool]

Deloitte May Be the #1 Firm of No Fun

heelys.jpgRegardless of who a client is or what their business is, accounting firms don’t like to lose them. Lost revenue, a little bit of a slap in the face, a promise that wasn’t delivered (which, let’s be honest, really isn’t all that rare).
For whatever reason, we find the story that Heelys, the skate shoe company, having fired Deloitte as their auditor, has to be an especially tough pill to swallow for the Big D.
Why, you may ask? How about the fact that Heelys MAKES SHOES THAT HAVE WHEELS ON THEM which might be something fun.
According to Reuters, Heelys gave Deloitte-period the heave-ho primarily because of cost considerations. That may be true but something tells us that the real reason might have been Deloitte putting the kibosh on Heelys request of the audit team to wear the skate shoes while working at the client’s HQ.
Deloitte, like all Big 4 firms, being the fun killer, likely argued that skate shoes did fall under acceptable attire in its dress code.
It was probably only a matter of time until the Heelys audit committee concluded that they had to find another audit firm with smaller sticks up their asses. Partners on the engagement are now quietly stewing with their decision that may have put their firm solidly in the #1 slot for hating all things fun.

Heelys dismisses accounting firm
[Reuters]