July 16, 2018

PCAOB Sanctions Former PwC Brazil Partner for Lousy Auditing

pwc legal us

You may have noticed, maybe not, but PwC is in the midst of a bad publicity streak. Last month, one partner screwed up the hand-off of the Best Picture envelope at the Oscars while the other partner froze. A few days later, federal agents raided Caterpillar’s headquarters over its offshore tax practices that PwC helped develop. And last but not least, the firm is slugging it out in court with MF Global and it doesn’t seem to be going well.

As we’ve noted, one Big 4 firm is usually hogging the spotlight for a series of blunders. EY had it for awhile last fall. Deloitte took over in December. And now PwC has dominated the late winter/early spring. One day, another Big 4 firm will succeed in bumbling into the role of Big 4 punching bag. Just not today:

The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board today announced sanctions against a former partner of PricewaterhouseCoopers Auditores Independentes in Brazil for audit failures and violations of PCAOB rules and standards.

Wander Rodrigues Teles was the lead partner for PwC Brazil’s 2010 and 2011 audit work on the Brazilian subsidiaries of Sara Lee Corporation, including Sara Lee Cafés do Brasil Ltda.

The PCAOB found that Teles failed to adequately respond to indications that Sara Lee Cafés may have overstated its accounts receivable.

How bad was that overstatement? Bad enough that Sara Lee had to restate its 2010 and 2011 results in 2012 where it cited “accounting irregularities in its Brazil operations, including the overstatement of accounts receivable.”

The PCAOB order is a pretty clinical read; you won’t find any embarrassing exchanges like there was in the Deloitte Brazil cover-up situation. Still, Teles ignored plenty of risks, didn’t require further testing where it was warranted, failed to recognize offsets to the receivables, etc. etc. The most orthodox of auditors will surely find it reprehensible.

As for punishment, the PCAOB fined Teles $10k and barred him from associating with a registered firm for two years. On the bright side, Warren Beatty doesn’t know who he is.

[PCAOB Press Release, Order]

Related articles

In Case You Need Another Reason to Hate the French

french flag.jpgWalking around the PwC office in Midtown Manhattan, our blogospondent in the field happened across a couple of young ladies having the picture taken in front of the P Dubya sign out front, proudly posing as if it was their names on the building at 300 Madison.
Said blogospondent approached the young ladies and asked if they worked at the P Dub and they responded in heavily French accents, “yes”. As result of further prying, it was revealed that the ladies do work a lot during “busy times”, sometimes between 50 and 60 hours a week!
This compared to an American tax associate who we spoke to just a couple days before who, in the last fifteen days, had worked 185 hours.
Let’s recap: America – 185 hours in 15 days in the middle of June vs. France – 50-60 hours in one week during the “busy time”.
American vitriol towards the French may now ensue.

SHOCKER: Doesn’t Appear that Stanford Auditors were Doing Any Auditing

allen-stanford_1018295c.jpgLast week’s indictment of Allen Stanford has brought up the always popular question when fraud, occurs: “Who are the auditors that were asleep at the wheel of this disaster?”
Well, in this case, the auditors were a local UK two-person shop, CAS Hewlett, which must be Queen’s English for Friehling & Horowitz.
It doesn’t appear that CAS Hewlett has a website, but they’ve been doing the Stanford “audits” for at least 10 years, so obv they’re legit. PwC and KPMG both have offices on Antigua but Stanford preferred to stay with its “trusted firm”. Totally understandable.
And the best part? The founder of the firm, Charlesworth “Shelly” Hewlett died in January, approximately a month before the story broke on the Ponz de Stanford.
This all adds up to who-the-fuck-knows if audits were even occurring and for us to speculate if Shelly needed to get got because Stan knew that the poo and fan were coming together. Just sayin’.