Accounting News Report, using data from Audit Analytics, puts out an Auditor Change Analysis every year and it usually finds its way into our inbox, however, because the analysis is a subscription-based publication (and a pricey one at that), reproducing the whole thing is usually not an option. This year we asked pretty please, and we got permission to show you a few of the charts from this year's edition. And lo and behold, who do we find at the top of the opining heap for 2011? Why, it's PwC's farm team, KPMG!
First, it's important to note that Audit Analytics is using publically available data for SEC registrants, so if you're a firm that is chasing dynamic, non-public clients for audit services, your efforts won't be reflected here. Just want to make sure we understand each other.
Now, then. This first chart shows change in ranking across various categories and, as you can see, the House of Klynveld led in 4 out of 5 categories.
The chart above makes a lot more sense when you couple it with this overall audit scoreboard:
The hard figures are interesting to go over and they can help you draw a number of conclusions (or wild-ass theories, depending on your perspective). For example, the increase in net gain of assets audited by KPMG is more or less equal the number of net loss of assets audited combined of Deloitte and PwC. Of course when you look at the net gain/loss in audit fees, KPMG's increase is far less than Deloitte and PwC's combined decrease. One might conclude that KPMG is doing more work for less money but if you then you might also conclude that the increase of +9 clients for KPMG and total -21 clients for Deloitte and P. Dubs basically makes it a wash.
*All tables were reproduced with permission from Accounting News Report.
Jay Duke will head up the assurance practice while Doug Sirotta will lead tax. They’ll both report to the most interesting CEO in the world.