The other day I asked my wife if she'd be mad if I started a new religion. I clarified that she would not be required to join my new religion; I just wanted to know if I'd have her support. She didn't really answer. Not out loud. But her nonverbal message was as clear as an auditing standard that was clarified in the Clarity Project1. What she wasn't saying was either (a) she'd be pissed if I really did it, or (b) she'll tolerate my stupid questions, or (c) she'd be shocked if I could get more religious followers than I have Twitter followers2.
My motivation for wanting to start a new religion was purely financial. L. Ron Hubbard was quoted as saying, "If you want to get rich, you start a religion." And I believe it, just like everything else L. Ron Hubbard said. Because if you start a religion, not only do you get to collect offerings from the faithful, but you get to do it tax-free as a 501(c)(3) organization. And churches don't even have to file a 990. My god3!
But I recently found out that there's an easier way. Instead of enduring the brain damage, persecution, and late-night angel-following that go along with starting your own religion, it's a lot easier to simply start embezzling money from a church that already exists. This was initially brought to my attention after listening to a recent Planet Money podcast.
Now, let's stop for just a second. I have songs by Duran Duran, Prince, and Frankie Goes To Hollywood on my metallic pink iPod nano, and I don't really care if, as a result, people think I'm gay. I've lived in Provo, Utah, for about 20 years, and I don't really care if people think I'm Mormon. But just because I subscribe to Planet Money, an NPR podcast, don't you dare assume for a second that I'm one of those pretentious assbags who begins every sentence with, "So I was listening to 'This American Life' on NPR the other day …"4 because I'm not! I'm a completely different type of pretentious assbag.
According to Episode 440 of Planet Money, 85 percent of Catholic dioceses reported embezzlements during the past five years. Of these, 11 percent reported total embezzlements over $500,000. And U.S. Catholic magazine says that 13 percent of the money given to all charitable institutions is lost to embezzlement.
It makes a lot of sense. Skimming cash would be pretty easy in a church because if someone puts cash in the offering plate, there's no way to get a receipt. Add to that an institutional resistance to internal controls and you've got yourself a fraud pentagram.
Since churches rely on sacred belief systems, internal controls might be viewed as a secular concern and either inherently evil or at a minimum unnecessary in churches. In fact, it might be considered insulting to church workers and volunteers to even imply that internal financial controls are important.
It's possible that churches could implement some basic aspects of the control environment component of the COSO Framework. Maybe churches could try to adopt some sort of code of ethics. Behavioral economist Dan Ariely's research shows that one way to reduce cheating is to get test-takers to recite the ten commandments prior to taking a test. By having his study participants do this one simple activity, cheating was completely eliminated.
And it's not as if the people who are more religious or who remember more commandments cheat less. In fact even when we get atheists to swear on the Bible, they don't cheat afterwards. So it's not about fear of God; it's about reminding people of their own moral standards.
So be careful. If you want to start stealing from God, you have to do whatever it takes to avoid the ten commandments when you're at church because they're sin-kryptonite5. Fortunately avoiding the ten commandments at church can't be too hard. People have been able to do it in more than four out of five Catholic dioceses.
2 Hey, sinners, follow @gregkyte to receive uplifting spiritual tweets every day!
3 Name, origin story, and mountain of residence yet to be determined.
4 Mom, I'm so sorry that you had to find out this way that I think you're a pretentious assbag.
5 Just try to read the ten commandments and then make a graven image. You can't do it.