The Dixon, Illinois Fraud Is the Latest Example of Why Reasonable Assurance Is Bullshit

As you know, the former CFO of DIxon, Illinois, Rita Crundwell, has been accused of misappropriating $30,236,503 and 51¢ from Ronald Reagan's boyhood home. It's a haul of Sue Sachdeva proportions, although it appears that obsessive shopping wasn't so much the motive as it was a My Little Pony fascination for a grown woman. ANYWAY, there seems to be a lot of questions about how such a fraud of this scope could go on undetected for so long, and could only be discovered when Ms. Crundwell took 12 weeks of unpaid vacation. A lot of people think both CliftonLarsonAllen, who compiled the city's financial statements, and Sam S. Card, CPA, the auditor of the financial statements bear some responsibility, but there's also the Illinois Comptroller's Office who is supposed to review the audited financial statements. 

It's interesting to note that CLA prepared both the compilation and the audit, prior to recommending Mr. Card to be the auditor. That occurred in 2006, around the time that the alleged fraud began. But before you get your knickers in a twist, someone would like to give you a refresher:

That doesn’t necessarily mean the auditor did anything wrong, said Mark Peecher, an accounting professor at the University of Illinois. “One of the things you need to keep in mind, there’s this thing called the expectation gap,” Peecher said. “The public thinks the audit does more than it does.” Even so, Peecher said he wouldn’t be shocked to find out the audit wasn’t up to par. “The probability that this happens and the person doesn’t get caught increases if the audit was of insufficient quality,” he said. “But even if the audit were up to standard, this could still happen and that would not be shocking.”
See? Audits can be great and fraud can still happen! And we wouldn't be shocked! OR audits can suck and fraud can still happen! And we wouldn't be shocked! There's really nothing you can do. The good professor knows, as all auditors, that most people out there don't have any idea of what an audit really is. Fine, an expectations gap. It's a crock, but again, there's really not much you can do about it. You an try to explain to your cousin in Dixon why it's not the auditor's job to detect frauds like this and (s)he would look at you, confused, and say, "Then what good is it?" AHA!
 
This is why the idea of reasonable assurance is bullshit. "Reasonable assurance" is just really just another way of saying, "in a perfect world where nothing out of the ordinary happens," except we live in a world where SHIT HAPPENS ALL THE TIME. Obsessive shoppers gone wild, mark-to-make-believe, repurchase accounting, insanely priced electronics, the list is endless. And auditors – large and small – can't do much about it.
 
So if you want to blame auditors, compilers, comptrollers for missing the horse lady's shenanigans, go ahead, they're used to it. But let's not pretend like auditors are really equipped to do a job that actually meets anyone's expectations or has any sort of value. And, really, aren't professional services supposed to accomplish both those things?

Related articles

acfe global fraud conference

5 Crazy Fraud Stories You Would Never Believe (If They Weren’t True)

From Russian government assassinations to multimillion-dollar blood-testing scams, there’s never a shortage of surreal fraud stories to rock the financial industry each year. And each year, the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) hosts the ACFE Global Fraud Conference to bring to life these hardly believable (yet true) financial cases by way of those who […]

PCAOB Releases Teaser Trailer of 2018 Inspection Findings

Testing internal control over financial reporting, assessing risks of material misstatement, and auditing accounting estimates (you know, the yoozh) continue to trip up auditors, according to the PCAOB, which offered a sneak preview of what we can expect in 2018 audit firm inspection reports. More than 160 U.S. audit firms were inspected by the PCAOB […]